Kara's Party Ideas Candy Corn Milkshake Recipe for Halloween! Kara's Party Ideas

Candy Corn Milkshakes! Perfect for a Halloween Party! Recipe on KarasPartyIdeas.com #candycorn #desserts #candycornmilkshakes #halloweenpartyideas #halloweendesserts #halloweendrinkrecipe (4)

I’m in love with these adorable HALLOWEEN CANDY CORN MILKSHAKES! They are so easy to make and make a fabulous addition to any halloween party, fall dinner party, or celebration!


1 Quart Vanilla Ice Cream
1 Quart Orange Sherbet
Whipped Cream or Cool Whip
Yellow Food Coloring
Black, Yellow & Orange Sprinkles

Mason Jars, Sprinkles and Black Chevron Paper Straws from Kara’s Party Ideas Shop

Directions below…

Candy Corn Milkshakes! Perfect for a Halloween Party! Recipe on KarasPartyIdeas.com #candycorn #desserts #candycornmilkshakes #halloweenpartyideas #halloweendesserts #halloweendrinkrecipe (3)

Speaking of Halloween Parties, how adorable are these bat halloween party invitations from Pear Tree Greetings that I came across today?! I LOVE that the invite doubles as a fun finger puppet! 


And how perfectly does this Candy Corn Invitation from Pear Tree Greetings go along with the candy corn milkshakes? I love the geometric pattern on the finished back of the invite.


Candy Corn Milkshake Recipe Directions:

Let your vanilla ice cream soften for about 25 minutes outside of the freezer. After the ice cream is softened take 1/3 of the ice cream and put it into a bowl and put the quart of vanilla ice cream back in the freezer. Add yellow food coloring to the ice cream in the bowl until the desired shade is obtained. Mix well.

Take your orange sherbet out of the freezer to allow it to start softening.

Get your mason jars, clear plastic cups, or glass drinking glasses and spoon yellow ice cream into the bottoms, filling the cups about 1/3 full. Smooth out the top as evenly as you can. Wipe down the inside of the cups with a paper towel to remove ice cream streaks. Place your cups in the freezer for 5-10 minutes to let the yellow layer harden a little.

Take your vanilla ice cream out of the freezer again to allow it to start softening.

Remove the cups from the freezer and carefully spoon in the orange sherbet now, filling the cups about 2/3 full, and again, smoothing out the top. Wipe the excess on the inside of the cups with a paper towel. Place the cups back in the freezer for 5-10 minutes.

Remove the cups from the freezer and add the final layer of vanilla ice cream, filling the cups within 1/2 inch from the top of the cup. Smooth out the tops again.

Top off your desserts with whipped cream or cool whip and sprinkles. Place in the freezer until they are ready to be served.

Yields about 10 milkshakes, depending on size of cups.

Leave a Reply

  1. Megan says:

    SO adorable!

  2. Kenzie Williams says:

    These will be perfect for my party! The kids will love them! Thank you!

  3. [email protected] says:

    These look like my candy corn milkshakes I created two years ago!

  4. Sue {munchkin munchies} says:

    I love these so much!

  5. makana hansen says:

    SO excited to make these!!!!

  6. Fatima says:

    Sorry for my ignorance but what is orange sherbet. Can’t wait to try it. Looks heavenly

  7. […] Candy Corn Milkshakes from Kara’s Party Ideas […]

  8. […] Candy Corn Milkshakes {Karas Party Ideas} […]

  9. […] Get the full recipe at KarasPartyIdeas.com […]